Home / Services / Tax Planning / LLC or S-Corp
The small business field guide

LLC or S-Corp: when the election pays, and when it does not

An LLC is a legal form. An S-Corp is a tax election. The election saves tax only on profit above a reasonable salary, and it brings costs of its own.

APAL LLC · Tax planning · 5-minute read

They are not opposites

An LLC is a legal form you create with the state. An S-Corp is a tax election you file with the IRS. An LLC can elect to be taxed as an S-Corp, and many do. So the real question is whether your business, whatever its legal form, should make the election.

What the election changes

Before and after an S-Corp election
How you are taxed on profitBefore: self-employment tax on nearly all of the profit. After: Social Security and Medicare apply to your salary only. Profit above the salary is not subject to them.
How you get paidBefore: you take draws. After: the company runs payroll and pays you a reasonable salary before any distributions.
ReturnsBefore: the business is on your personal return. After: the company files its own return every year, and you get a Schedule K-1.
State taxesIt depends on the state. Some states tax the company itself and others do not. California, for example, charges an LLC an $800 annual tax, plus a fee at higher income, and charges an S-Corp 1.5 percent of net income with an $800 minimum. We check your state before running the numbers.

The salary is the hinge

The IRS expects an owner who works in the business to be paid reasonable compensation as wages before taking distributions. There is no formula. It looks at your duties, your experience, the time you put in, and what comparable businesses pay for the same work. A salary set too low is the most common way the election gets challenged.

The election only saves tax on profit above that salary. If the business earns about what your job is worth, there is little or nothing left to save on.

The math, and what it leaves out

A fictional sole proprietor with $120,000 of profit

Without the election: self-employment tax applies to about 92 percent of the profit at 15.3 percent, close to $17,000.

With the election and a $70,000 salary: Social Security and Medicare on the salary, both halves, come to about $10,700. That is roughly $6,200 less.

Then subtract: a smaller qualified business income deduction, because wages paid to you reduce it; any state tax on the company, such as California's franchise tax; the separate business return; payroll costs; and federal and state unemployment tax on your own wages.

At this profit level those give-backs can take most of the saving. As profit climbs well above a reasonable salary, the saving grows faster than the costs. That is why the answer comes from your numbers and not from a rule of thumb. This is a teaching example with rounded figures, not an APAL client story.

Timing

Form 2553 is due during the prior tax year, or within two months and 15 days of the start of the year the election takes effect. For an existing calendar-year business that is March 15. A new business counts the two months and 15 days from the day its first tax year starts. The IRS offers late-election relief when its conditions are met, so a missed deadline is not always the end of it.

When to go the other way

An S-Corp that no longer earns much above the owner's salary is paying for payroll, a second return and any state tax on the company without much in return. That is worth a review too. Undoing an election has its own tax effects, so it gets the same look at the numbers first.

What to bring to a planning call

  1. Last year's return and this year's profit so far.
  2. What you do in the business and how many hours.
  3. Whether you already run payroll.
  4. How the business is set up today: sole proprietor, LLC, partnership or corporation.

Want the S-Corp question answered on your numbers?

APAL plans and sets up these moves for small business owners, remotely across the U.S. and in person in the Sacramento area. Tell us how the business is set up today.

Book a free consultation

See APAL's tax planning service and business formation, or read about accountable plans and paying your children.

Sources and scope

Rules checked November 16, 2026 against the IRS page on S corporation compensation, the Form 2553 instructions and, for the California example, the FTB page on S corporations. The example is fictional and its figures are rounded. This guide is general education, not advice for your situation.